Goofy mh problem
jc at trillian.mit.edu
jc at trillian.mit.edu
Wed Oct 25 12:20:13 EDT 2000
Hi; me again. It occurs to me that maybe someone here will be
familiar with the mh mailer, and might have a solution to one of the
silliest email problems I've seen yet (and I've seen a lot of them).
I thought I'd give mh a try, after not using it for years, since it's
now available on linux and bsd systems and seems to basically work.
However, when I started using mh on this machine, something that
rapidly came to my attention was that a lot of people couldn't reply
to my messages. The reason turned out to be that it was sending
messages out with the header line like:
From: <jc at trillian.mit.edu>, <jc at localhost>
From: John Chambers <jc at localhost.mit.edu>
In test that I've done sending myself messages, I've seen both of
these. Needless to say, jc at localhost is of little use to people on
other machines, and jc at localhost.mit.edu simply bounces. The first
example seems to work with most Unix-type mailers, but Microsoft
mailers discard the first address and use the second one. Duh!
One of the funny cases is that when mediaone users try to reply to
this, their mail servers know how to deliver it, to someone called
"jc" in their own system. He knows about me and has forwarded me a
few messages, but I'd rather not bother him with messages intended
for me.
Anyhow, several people who have used mh have told me that they are
sure there's a simple way to configure mh to send out the right
return address. Unfortunately, while they insist that it's simple,
they can't actually tell me how to do it. Something that you can't
type isn't all that useful, no matter how simple it is. We've spent
far too much time grovelling around in TFM pages, and not finding it.
Anyone know? Or should I just dismiss mh as not usable yet?
(Funny thing is, on this machine, the /usr/bin/mail command does the
same thing. But the hostname and uname commands give the correct DNS
name for this machine. Why both of these mailers do something so
bogus is a real mystery. One of our linux machines at work does the
same thing, and nobody there can diagnose it, either. We have had a
couple of comments that soon the pwd command will start saying just
".", which is of course absolutely true. ;-)
-
Subcription/unsubscription/info requests: send e-mail with
"subscribe", "unsubscribe", or "info" on the first line of the
message body to discuss-request at blu.org (Subject line is ignored).
More information about the Discuss
mailing list